Sleepover Mishaps [HQ Captains x Reader] Part 2

Nibbling on the fifth cookie that you’ve had for the night, you glanced up at the clock. It was now 8:45 PM, 20 minutes after the incident happened.

Should I go back there now?

Your gaze absentmindedly wandered to the cookie jar in front of you. Noticing a rather small label at the other side of the transparent jar, you turned it around.

With big bold letters, it read


‘SECRET COOKIE JAR OF TOORU! DON’T TOUCH OR EAT IF YOU ARE NOT ME!’

You almost choked on your cookie as you read the word ‘secret’.

Well, it wasn’t much of a secret as you immediately saw it when you rummaged through one of the kitchen cupboards.

You panicked as you closed the jar and glanced side to side if anyone saw you eating.

Should I place it back on the cupboard? Oikawa might notice that it was tampered with! And I’m the only one not in his room right now, so..

Quickly finishing the cookie, you secured the lid and hugged the jar tight to your body.

Please don’t be mad. Please don’t be mad. Please don’t be mad. You chanted as you made your way to his room.

You then remembered what Oikawa said when you eavesdropped. Oh no, they think I’m mad!

Muffled voices could be heard from the other side as you stopped in front of the door. Lightly knocking, you gave a deep sigh before you opened it.

“Oikawa-san!” you winced at your loud voice before continuing, “I f-forgive you. But, you must forgive me too.”

Oikawa’s lit up face cocked to the side in inquiry, and you smiled anxiously as you showed him his cookie jar.

“I ate 5 cookies, I’m sorry.” You ended the sentence in a whisper as you stared at the floor, not daring to meet his eyes.

“..my cookies.” His eyes widened, mouth agape.

“I’m sorry Oikawa-san! I really am! It was too late when I noticed the label and then I panic–“

“(F/N)-chaaan, how meaaan! How could you not notice that label with such beautiful handwriting?” He pouted as he stood up and walked towards where you were.

“I-I’m sorry!” you squeaked as you felt his calloused hands cup yours which were still holding the cookie jar.

“It’s okay, (F/N)-chan, you can have them.” You opened your mouth to speak in retaliation as you looked up to him, but he cut you off by saying, “Accept it as a gift of apology for the thing that I have done earlier.”

You swore you saw the tips of his ears redden as he said those words.

You giggled softly at his embarrassment, “Okay, Oikawa-san. If you say so.”

Oikawa removed his hands from yours and placed it on the small of your back, pushing you gently towards where the other captains sat.

“Look who decided to return!” Terushima teased you in a sing song voice.

You stuck your tongue out to him and nudged his body with your foot, “Shush, now scoot over and let me sit.”

Terushima patted on his lap, “You can always sit here, (F/N).”

You blushed and shuffled to the other side of the circle which they formed, “No thank you, Teru-san. I find the cots more comfortable at this moment.”

Ushijima moved to his left to give you some space to sit with them and you thanked him.

“Soo, what’re you guys up to?”

You opened the jar as Kuroo replied, “We started to talk about our future.”

Humming as you thought, you offered Moniwa, who was at your right, a cookie.

“Why that, of all topics? You’re all great volleyball players, I’m pretty sure I would see all of you playing for the national team. ” Moniwa thanked you and you dug another cookie to give to Ushijima, in which he politely shook his head to.

After offering the rest of them with cookies, Moniwa was the one who responded this time, “Oh. Not that kind of future, (L/N)-san.”

“Eh? What do you mean?”

“Future wife.” Ushijima shortly stated.

“Oh?” This caught your interest. What lucky girls would their wives be.

"Oikawa here, just started talking about some girl which was going to be his future wife.” Bokuto pointed his cookie towards Oikawa who was eating his own.

“Yup. She definitely will be my future wife.” Oikawa nodded in agreement to what Bokuto said. “I mean, who wouldn’t want her to be his future wife?”

“Elaborate, Oikawa.” Daichi mumbled while munching on his cookie.

“Well, she’s good looking, not more than me of course. Even though she doesn’t wear make-up, she's still pretty.” Oikawa finishes his cookie before continuing,

“Next, she’s really kind. She never fails to amaze me every single time she reaches out to something or someone. It’s like her kindness knows no limits.” Kuroo hummed in approval at this.

“She always listens to my problems; no matter how big or trivial it seems, she's always there for me. And it kinda lightens the weight that I carry whenever I feel pressured, you know? It's like she knows the right words to say at that moment, and she tries to lighten up the atmosphere afterwards by saying some stupid joke.”

“She sounds like a really nice person, Oikawa-san.” Moniwa says, interrupting Oikawa’s monologue.

“Yes, she really is.” Oikawa smiled and continued his rant about the girl, describing her with such pleasant words, but strangely familiar attributes.

Mid-rant, Terushima suddenly states “She sounds just like the girl I like.”

“Mine too.” Bokuto stares at Oikawa unblinkingly.

“Same here.” Kuroo tilts his head in acknowledgement while Ushijima grunts in approval.

Moniwa and Daichi also made gestures of confirmation, telling the others that they also think so.

You felt a change in the atmosphere between the guys as they stared with each other, while you ate the last cookie.

“Um, g-guys,” you tried to break the tension but you were suddenly cut off.

“Does she like (Favorite Movie)?” Kuroo asks Oikawa and he nodded in affirmation.

“She likes to read, especially the (favorite genre) kind.” Another nod.

“She can become clingy when she’s comfortable with you, right?” Another nod.

“She’s shorter than us.” A chuckle and another nod.

“She’s has the weirdest and most random demands.” Another nod.

“She knows how to cook and likes (Favorite food).” Another nod.

The tension grew thicker as they rapid-fired question after question, and you felt yourself squirming in your position.


I think she sounds familiar. Have I met her already? Hmm. You furrowed your face as you thought.

Their voices grew louder and their stares harder. Some of them clenched their fists as they, except you, all thought at the same time




‘We all like the same girl’

Deciding to speak, you cleared your throat and said something which made them break off their little war, “If you guys continue ignoring me, I’m going to leave.”

They all stared at you with astonished eyes and exclaimed at the same time, “Don’t!”

You looked at all of them in surprise and laughed.

“I’m just gonna go down to place this in the kitchen and drink water. I think I ate too many cookies.” You frowned at this and left the room, again.

The room was encased in a few minutes of silence before Kuroo said, “We’re talking about the same girl aren’t we?”

They all nodded.

A few seconds passed before Terushima spoke, “She’s kind of dense, isn’t she?”

“I think she finds the cookies more interesting than anything else, right now.”

“…”

“…”

“…”

“…”

Bokuto stands and stretches his body lazily, “Well I don’t know about you guys but I’m going doooown,” he finishes his sentences as he shot towards the door.

Daichi, quick to react, also stood up and muttered before going, “I think I’d like to have some water.”

The rest immediately followed, making lame excuses that were paid no heed to.

One minute, you were just placing the empty glass on the kitchen counter and the next, you found yourself thrown over Bokuto’s shoulder.

“H-hey! What are you doing, Bokuto! Put me down this instant!”

“Let’s watch a movie right now, (F/N)-chaaaan!”

“What about the others?”

“They won–"

Rushed, heavy footsteps from the stairs could be heard as a voice, probably Terushima, cried “I CALL DIBS ON (F/N)’S RIGHT SIDE!”

Bokuto immediately placed you on the very corner of the couch and sat on your left side.

“There’s no right side now! MWAHAHAHA!”

The living room turned into a battleground as soon as all the other captains were on sight. Oikawa and Terushima quickly pounced on Bokuto, making the couch fall; Ushijima, Daichi, and Kuroo were having the most intense glaring contest that you've ever seen.

You tumbled along with the couch as it fell, making you fall backwards with your legs sticking up in the air. Moniwa immediately rushed towards you and helped you up. 


"O-ow."


The simple sound made the other captains stop their fight and look towards you. Bokuto, horrified to have remembered the couch fell, immediately looked at you in fear and said, "My precious (F/N)-chan feeeeeeeeeell!" 


"Eh, it's okay Bokuto. It doesn't really hurt." you laughed awkwardly as you tried to comfort the captain who was starting to be depressed. 


"B-but,"


"It's okay, really." Bokuto pouted as he saw you rub the back of your head. Ah, I could feel a bruise forming. 


"Pick the movie (L/N). We'll clean up the mess THEY made." Ushijima turned his stare sharply to the three who wrestled – whom in return immediately stiffened.


"Are you guys fine with that?"


Chorused replies of affirmation answered you.


"Hmm, okay." you walked towards Oikawa's collection of movies and placed both of your hands on your hips while looking for a good one. 


"Aha! Let's watch this!" you held up a disc and showed it to them.


Watching some of them pale, you knew it was the right choice. 


A subtle, not so innocent smirk was plastered on your face as you flicked the TV on and placed the disc in the DVD Player. 






Oh come on, it's just Frozen.